Granted there are a lot of lines in this play that make me nearly pee myself they’re so simply pleasurable to read.
But this line in particular is the keystone for me, the line that everything rests on for Sugar, sweet Sugar Ducharme. I love the line and I love what it implies: that a person can cram unit after unit of “love” inside of them and pressure cook, compress these feelings, year after year after year until it becomes a kind of a danger. If one does not sufficiently dole out their love with measured regularity one becomes a hazard to their own health and those around them.
I think people who suppress–people like Sugar, who squeeze all their feelings into a zipper-busting-duffel-of-a-hear—feel a little like they ate too much mac and cheese for dinner. Uncomfortable in their guts and in their own skin. Compounded by a decade. If this suppression, this dissatisfaction, this emotional malnourishment continues for too long the idea of transparency becomes a kind of terrifying hope. Please please, the body begs, let me have one small moment of honesty! But please please, let me keep hiding because I don’t know if I’ll be able to handle even that much truth in a day. We humans so often crave honesty from those around us, but only on our terms.
There was a moment—more like an hour—in rehearsal last Thursday that was painfully transparent for me as an actor—not just as Sugar. I’ve been in awe of that hour ever since. Anyone who’s been a part of a rehearsal process, or any kind of passionately charged relationship, will admit that terror exists in the moments where all of a sudden you realize you and the people surrounding you don’t view the world the same way. It’s jarring, strange, and unnerving. Like falling asleep in a land where everyone speaks your mother-tongue and then waking to realize you don’t even know how to communicate your need to find a water-closet. I exaggerate—but only slightly. When I walked into Thursday’s rehearsal I had a much much different view of the end of the play. ‘I thought I knew my own home as well as I knew my own face—as well as I know yours,’ Sugar says in one of the final scenes, ‘I didn’t, I don’t.’
I have harbored a lot of love for this play: we all have. Katie and Louisa for over a year, and Sean and I both since January. It is a play to love, “a filth to nest in,” as Claudia Dey puts it. So it’s difficult to realize that this beautiful Canadian world I’ve been living in isn’t necessarily the same one the rest of the creative team has had in their heads.
There were two ways we could have dealt with this: the Easy-Hard, and the Hard-Hard.
The Easy-Hard is going with the flow of rehearsal. This is how you all see it, fine I’ll make it work, no questions asked. This is Easy-Hard because saying ‘yes’ to everything is so easy, and feels so good, so yielding, and loving, and in the moment. It’s hard because if it’s not TRUE you end up paying for that ‘easy yes’ for a long time afterwards.
The Hard-Hard involves nothing but the capital-T the Truth. It involves transparency. It involves recognizing the thing you love and naming it, aloud. The Hard-Hard puts your guts out there on the table, and dares you to put it together. Even worse: in rehearsal, this has to happen around other people, with their hands working alongside your own.
We went the Hard-Hard. That night in rehearsal, there was a lot of honesty. A lot of gnarled love-regret-disappointments rearing their heads.
This play was darker than I realized. I knew the ending wasn’t all cherry pie, but it took being completely honest about my own feelings about the play to be able to really HEAR what everyone else was saying.
We went through it again and again, the last five minutes of the scene, and miraculously, painfully, change happened. I saw what it was that I was missing before, and it hurt. I realized, in a way, that I myself had been hiding from the real meat of the scene: the meat of the play. We all hope that love is triumphant, that it can be a balm for all wounds: and it can. But like that “bomb waiting to go off,” love holds no prisoners, and wherever there is triumph there is also loss and a great moving-on.
Earlier, I mentioned those lines, ‘I thought I knew my own home as well as I knew my own face—as well as I know yours…’ they continue. ‘I only needed to travel one mile to see it for what it really is.’ It’s frustrating to realize you’re not on the same page. It’s humbling and beautiful to feel your mind and heart physically changed by those around you. It’s a down right MIRACLE to discover that a new Truth might be waiting just on the other side of your front door.
-Sugar Ducharme
(alias Becky Webber)